Daily brief · Market & Mortgage

The 16-Year Standoff

The 16-Year Standoff

The American housing market is officially in a deep freeze. Mortgage rates are stubbornly high, and home prices refuse to budge. We're seeing the fewest homes change hands since the dusty aftermath of the Great Recession. It's a classic standoff. Buyers can't afford the math, and sellers won't give up their pandemic-era low rates.

3.75MAnnual sales pace
$416,700October median price
7.11%30-year fixed rate

Why today's rates hit harder

It's tempting to look at today's interest rates and shrug. Borrowing costs were right around this level back in 1997, and plenty of people bought houses then. But the math is fundamentally broken, as CNBC recently pointed out.

Back in the late nineties, home prices were tethered to what a normal family actually earned. Today, a typical monthly mortgage payment has ballooned to $2,291. Paychecks grew over the last three decades, but home prices skyrocketed at almost double that pace. That leaves a massive gap between what a house costs and what a working family can comfortably afford.

The waiting game

Because regular buyers are squeezed, the people actually closing deals right now are the ones who don't need a bank. Cash buyers are swooping up 29% of all homes sold. They're tapping into the massive equity they built up over the last few years. First-time buyers are pushed out of the picture entirely.

For everyone else, the strategy is simple: wait.

The number of homes sitting on the market quietly crept up to its highest level in 11 years, according to Realtor.com. Sellers are finally listing their properties, but buyers are dragging their feet. They're hoping something gives.

Where the standoff is cracking

If you want to see where this market is starting to break, look out West. In Utah, specifically the Salt Lake City area, 31.8% of all listings saw a price reduction last month. Sellers are realizing the pandemic frenzy is over. They have to adjust their expectations if they actually want to move.

Buyers in the area are taking a uniquely polite approach. Instead of throwing out aggressive lowball offers, they're sitting on the sidelines and letting sellers lower the asking price on their own. It's a quiet rebellion, and it's working.

The bottom line

  • If you're trying to buy, patience is your best asset while inventory slowly builds. Check our buying a home guide for tips on spotting a motivated seller.
  • If you plan to list, price it right the first time. The days of multiple offers over asking are mostly behind us. Our selling your home walkthrough covers exactly how to prep your property for a slower market.
  • If you bought recently when rates briefly spiked, keep a close eye on the weekly averages. Use our mortgage refinance calculator to see if a small drop makes it worth pulling the trigger.
Sources: The New York Times · Realtor.com · CNBC · Realtor.com Every figure links to its original report.

← All homeowner news